Companions
Challenge
Blog
←Back to Blog
Mental Health

Grief During the Holidays: The First Season Without Them, and What to Say No To

ILTY TeamILTY Team•November 16, 2026•15 min read

In crisis? Call or text 988 in the US, 9-8-8 in Canada, or find your country's line at findahelpline.com.

The first message lands in the second week of November: "Are we still doing Thanksgiving at yours?" You are in a grocery store aisle holding the brand of coffee only he drank, and you have no idea how to answer. He died in March. Everyone has been kind. Nobody has told you what to do about his chair.

By December the question gets louder: the box of decorations with his handwriting on the lid, the aunt asking if you are "up to it", the office party you already accepted. A lot of advice about grief during the holidays boils down to "keep busy and get through it", and Wolfelt, of the Center for Loss, warns that busyness on its own can add stress.

The first holidays after a death are not a test you pass by keeping busy and smiling; they are a handful of specific hours you can plan, shorten, decline or leave, and the evidence is clearer about what not to force than about what you must do.

This post is for the first season after a death; for the wider December survival kit, see the holiday anxiety guide.

The first holidays after a death: what you will actually feel

Expect the wrong feelings at the wrong moments, and more ordinary hours than anyone warned you about. Both are normal.

Maciejewski, Zhang, Block and Prigerson (2007) followed 233 bereaved people from one to 24 months after a loss. The average peaks did fall roughly in stage order (disbelief around month one, yearning around four, anger around five, low mood around six), but acceptance was the most endorsed feeling from the first month, and yearning, not depression, dominated the negative ones. That is an average curve, not a path any one person walks, though it helps explain why a December four or five months out can feel angrier than the first weeks did.

Most people do not collapse. Bonanno and colleagues (2002) followed 205 people from before a loss to 18 months after it. The largest group showed a resilient pattern: steady functioning and relatively low distress. Chronic grief was predicted by how dependent the person had been on the one who died. If you got through a Tuesday this week without crying, you are not doing it wrong.

Why the five stages will not predict it

The Elisabeth Kübler-Ross Foundation notes that the stages "began as descriptions of responses among dying patients" in 1969 and "can overlap, repeat, or be skipped"; our guide to processing grief takes the myth apart.

The new jobs count as grieving too

Stroebe and Schut (1999) describe two kinds of stress after a death: the loss itself, and everything it rearranges. Learning to carve because he always did, hosting for the first time, sorting the bills: in their dual process model, those count as coping with the death too. Adaptive coping moves back and forth between the two, and time away from the loss is part of it.

Nor are you supposed to let go. The continuing bonds research edited by Klass, Silverman and Nickman (1996) argued that resolving grief well can mean keeping a continuing bond with the person who died, not cutting it. Setting out his mug or telling his story at the table is not clinging.

Why does grief feel worse at the holidays? What the evidence says about December

Grief can come back hard around dates that matter. Writing for psychiatrists, Zisook and Shear (2009) describe acute grief returning "around the time of significant events, such as holidays, birthdays, anniversaries" even after it has eased. In one of the few studies to test that, Carr, Sonnega, Nesse and House (2014) followed older spouses (297 people at the six-month interview, 210 of them widowed). At six months, depressive symptoms were elevated in the late spouse's birthday month and in January. By 18 months no special-occasion effect remained.

The ten people interviewed in December showed no significant elevation, and nobody was interviewed in Christmas week. December, in other words, was barely measured. Plan January the way you are planning the 25th.

What is an anniversary reaction?

An anniversary reaction is grief that returns around a date tied to the loss, such as the death day, the birthday or the first holiday: the recurrence Zisook and Shear describe.

How do you cope with grief during the holidays? Start with what you say no to

Decide in advance, say it early, and give yourself an exit. Doka's three Cs for the Hospice Foundation of America, Choose, Communicate, Compromise, are a useful frame: choose which events and traditions you will do, tell people before the day, and compromise where you can (go "only for dessert", or decide on the morning rather than in November).

Invitations and traditions

Every tradition has three honest options this year: as it was, differently, or not at all. Someone else cooks; the stockings stay in the attic. None of these is a verdict on the person who died, and none has to be permanent. Decline the invitations you dread first, because dread is worth listening to this year.

"Keeping busy" is not the same as taking a break from grief

Wolfelt's holiday guidance is blunt: "merely 'keeping busy' won't distract you from your grief, but may actually increase stress". Yet time away from grief is adaptive, and Bonanno, Keltner, Holen and Horowitz (1995) found that people avoiding painful emotion at six months showed minimal grief through 14 months. Turning away is not automatically harmful; the risk is the pattern. Eisma and Stroebe (2021) reviewed 64 studies covering 7,715 bereaved people and found "strong evidence that experiential avoidance and rumination play a role in the persistence of complicated grief".

SignTaking a break (fine)Chronic avoidance (the risk)
What it looks likeOne evening out, a game with the kids, a long drive with musicEvery hour from now to New Year booked; a new project started the day after the funeral
AfterwardsThe grief returns and you let itYou add another task

You will also be told you have to talk about it. In two prospective studies, Stroebe, Stroebe, Schut, Zech and van den Bout (2002) found "no evidence that disclosure facilitated adjustment". Talking may help if you want to and have someone who can listen without fixing; it is not a duty. Mr. Relentless would put it this way: you don't owe anyone a performance of grief, and you don't owe anyone a performance of fine.

Scripts: answering "how are you", declining without reasons, asking for what you need

Have the sentences ready; the question will come while you are holding a plate. For "how are you", pick one true line that ends the exchange on your terms: "Today's a hard one. Ask me about the kids." "Rough, and glad to be here. What's new with you?" Why "fine" stopped working covers the longer version.

For declining, The Compassionate Friends' advice to bereaved parents works for anyone: you do not have to give reasons. Their scripts are "No thanks." "I just can't." "I won't be doing it this year." Say one and stop.

For asking, be specific enough that someone can do it:

  1. "Will you sit next to me?"
  2. "If I leave early, don't follow me out. I'll text when I'm home."
  3. "Say his name. I would rather hear it than not."
  4. "Can you take the cooking this year? I'll bring dessert."

What do you say to someone grieving at the holidays?

Use the name and acknowledge the change. Cruse's guidance on what to say at Christmas suggests opening with "I know this might feel different this year" rather than a cheerful script. Ask what they want ("Do you want us to do the toast, or skip it?") instead of deciding for them. The phrases that land badly ("at least", "they'd want you to be happy") are collected in toxic positivity in grief.

Rituals for the first holidays: the candle, the name, the toast

In three experiments by Norton and Gino (2014), performing a ritual after a loss reduced grief. The effect ran through an increased sense of control, and it held whether or not participants believed in rituals. The practical reading is to decide the sequence yourself: a time and a first move ("after we sit down, I light the candle"). The three below come from bereavement organizations, not the experiments.

  • The candle. Light one as the meal starts, or join The Compassionate Friends' Worldwide Candle Lighting, held since 1997 on the second Sunday in December at 7 pm local time.
  • The name. Wolfelt's advice is to "include the person's name in your holiday conversation". One story, told by whoever wants to tell it.
  • The toast. One sentence, then the meal goes on. Cruse's ways to remember someone add an ornament, their favorite film and a memory round.

The empty chair, a place set for the person who died, is folk practice; no bereavement organization we could find recommends it. It may comfort one family and feel like a two-hour reproach to another. Decide together before the day, and if unsure, choose a ritual that lasts a minute rather than the whole meal.

Alcohol, sleep and the body during the holidays

Grief is physical, and the season adds drink and subtracts sleep. The Lancet review by Stroebe, Schut and Stroebe (2007) found the risk of death highest "particularly in the early weeks and months after loss". If the death was recent, treat yourself like someone recovering, not someone performing.

In a Hungarian national survey of 4,457 people, Pilling and colleagues (2012) found that 29.8% of men bereaved two years earlier drank at risky levels, against 12.9% of non-bereaved men, with no difference among women and none at three years. One country, one survey, but men in the first two years are the group to watch.

The US National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism defines a binge as about five drinks for men or four for women in about two hours. Its drink refusal worksheet was not written for the holidays, but it fits: rehearse the refusal aloud, keep an alcohol-free drink in your hand, plan your exit, and treat "No, thank you" as complete.

Sleep may well be worse. Lancel, Stroebe and Eisma (2020) reviewed 85 articles covering 12,294 participants: sleep problems are common after bereavement and track grief intensity, and no intervention has yet targeted sleep in bereaved people. Ask a doctor anyway if poor sleep lasts weeks. Any new physical symptom (chest pain, breathlessness, fainting) gets a clinician first and a grief explanation second.

When it is more than grief: prolonged grief disorder, at 12 months or six

Under the US DSM-5-TR, prolonged grief disorder cannot be diagnosed in adults until at least 12 months after the death; under the WHO's ICD-11, the line is six months (Eisma, 2023). The American Psychiatric Association's summary adds that at least three of eight symptoms must have been present nearly every day for the last month.

It is a minority outcome. Lundorff and colleagues (2017) pooled 14 studies and estimated 9.8% of bereaved adults (confidence interval 6.8 to 14.0), higher in older samples, with doubts about how well the studies generalize; the psychiatric association estimates 4% to 15%. Zisook and Shear put it plainly: most bereaved people do fine without treatment.

When they do not, treatment helps many of them. In randomized trials, 51% responded to 16 sessions of grief-specific therapy against 28% with interpersonal therapy (Shear and colleagues, 2005), and among completers given CBT, 14.8% still met criteria at six months with exposure added, against 37.9% without it (Bryant and colleagues, 2014).

Watch for grief you organize your life around avoiding, thoughts you cannot stop circling (the avoidance and rumination Eisma and Stroebe linked to grief that persists), and drinking that has become the plan. If the hours between gatherings are the hard part, support for grief and loss is a reasonable interim step. A professional is the right one if the grief is not easing, at any point: you do not need to wait for a diagnostic threshold.

December has the lowest suicide rate of any month in recent US data (twelfth of twelve in CDC figures for 2024, per the Annenberg Public Policy Center), which says nothing about how this December feels to you. If you are thinking about suicide or feel you cannot keep going, call or text 988 in the US, 9-8-8 in Canada, or find your country's line at findahelpline.com.

Frequently asked questions

Is it OK to skip the holidays when you are grieving? Yes. Choosing what to attend is the first of Doka's three Cs, and The Compassionate Friends are explicit that you do not owe anyone a reason. If avoiding every reminder has become the pattern, that is worth raising with someone, whenever it happens.

Are the five stages of grief real? They describe feelings people have, not an order anyone has to follow. The stages came from Kübler-Ross's work with dying patients, and in the 2007 JAMA test of the model, acceptance was the most endorsed feeling from the first month while yearning dominated the negative ones.

How long does grief last? There is no fixed endpoint, but intensity usually falls. In Maciejewski's 24-month study the negative feelings peaked by about month six, and in the Clayton data cited by Zisook and Shear, 42% of bereaved people met symptom criteria for major depression at one month and 16% at a year. In adults, prolonged grief disorder cannot be diagnosed before 12 months under DSM-5-TR, or six under ICD-11.

Sources and further reading

ILTY is for 11pm on December 24, when the house is quiet and nobody else is awake to hear the name. Tell Mr. Relentless or the Mindful Guide what the day was actually like; the conversation ends with two to four concrete things to do next (the leaving time, the candle, the one person to text), and because ILTY remembers what you said, it asks how they went the next time you talk. It is not therapy and not a crisis service, and it will not tell you which stage you are in. On iPhone and Android. Start the 7-day trial.

#grief during the holidays#grief#bereavement#first holiday without a loved one#prolonged grief#holiday stress

Share this article

ILTY Team

ILTY Team

AI Mental Health Companion

Building an AI companion that actually helps with your mental health.

Get mental health insights in your inbox

No fluff, no toxic positivity — just what actually helps.

Related Support

ILTY can help with what you're reading about.