ILTY vs BetterHelp
BetterHelp offers real therapy with licensed professionals — at $280-400/month, with reported use of AI to generate replies, and a 2023 FTC settlement behind it. ILTY is $12.99/month for tough-love AI that’s honest about being AI. Different tools, different price, different trust story.
Quick Summary
BetterHelp is best if:
- ✓You need treatment for a clinical condition
- ✓You want an ongoing relationship with a therapist
- ✓You can afford $300-400/month
- ✓You want professional expertise and credentials
ILTY is best if:
- ✓You need support but not clinical treatment
- ✓You need to talk at 2am and can't wait for a session
- ✓Cost is a barrier to therapy access
- ✓You want support between therapy sessions
About BetterHelp
BetterHelp launched in 2013 and is one of the largest online therapy platforms, now part of Teladoc. It connects you with licensed therapists for text messaging, live chat, phone calls, and video sessions. Claimed scale: 32,000+ therapists, 6.3M+ users helped.
The platform has faced compounding criticism over the past several years. In 2023, the FTC required a $7.8 million settlement for sharing user health data with advertisers including Facebook, Snapchat, and Pinterest. In 2024, parent company Teladoc recorded a $720M goodwill impairment on BetterHelp. Journalism and Reddit communities have surfaced persistent complaints about variable therapist quality, low therapist pay ($30/hr), refund refusals, and reports of therapists using AI to draft replies — while the platform markets itself as human-centered.
None of this means BetterHelp is worthless. Licensed therapy is real therapy, and for people who can’t access in-person care, BetterHelp is still a real option. But the $280-400/month price tag and the trust issues are real too, and they matter when you’re choosing where to spend your mental-health budget.
About ILTY
ILTY is a tough-love AI mental health companion. It’s not therapy — it’s AI-powered conversation for everyday mental health moments, explicit about being AI, and priced like software rather than like a human professional.
Five companions (Mr. Relentless, Stoic Advisor, The Architect, Mindful Guide, Ember) give you range. When you need tough love, Mr. Relentless names what you’re avoiding. When you need softness, Mindful Guide holds space. Every conversation ends with a concrete next step. Available 24/7, no scheduling, no waiting rooms, no surprise data-sharing lawsuits.
$12.99/mo or $99.99/yr (7-day free trial). That’s about 95% cheaper than BetterHelp’s $280-400/mo — and ILTY is transparent about being AI, not a human pretending with AI assistance. For serious clinical conditions, see a licensed therapist. For the everyday moments, ILTY is the honest tool.
Detailed Comparison
What You're Talking To
BetterHelp
Licensed human therapists—psychologists, clinical social workers, licensed counselors. Reports indicate some BetterHelp therapists use AI tools to draft replies, which the platform does not disclose to users.
ILTY
AI companions built for mental health conversations. Honest about being AI — no human pretending with AI in the loop.
Better for: BetterHelp for human expertise (when you actually get a human); ILTY for honest AI
Availability
BetterHelp
Scheduled sessions (video/phone) + asynchronous messaging. Therapist responds within their schedule.
ILTY
Instant, 24/7. No scheduling, no waiting.
Better for: ILTY
Cost
BetterHelp
$280-400/month ($70-100/week). Doesn’t accept insurance (may provide receipts for reimbursement). HSA/FSA eligible in some cases.
ILTY
$12.99/mo or $99.99/yr (7-day trial). Roughly 95% cheaper than BetterHelp on a monthly basis.
Better for: ILTY by 20-30x on monthly cost
Depth of Support
BetterHelp
Real therapeutic relationship. Can treat clinical conditions. Continuity over time.
ILTY
Supportive conversations. Not clinical treatment. No ongoing relationship memory (yet).
Better for: BetterHelp for clinical needs
For Serious Conditions
BetterHelp
Appropriate for depression, anxiety disorders, trauma, and other clinical conditions (with right therapist match).
ILTY
Not appropriate as primary treatment for serious conditions. Supplemental support only.
Better for: BetterHelp
Privacy & Trust
BetterHelp
2023 FTC settlement: $7.8M for sharing user health data with Facebook, Snapchat, Pinterest, and other advertisers. HIPAA-compliant today, but the trust hit is fresh. 2024 Teladoc $720M goodwill impairment reflects ongoing reputational pressure.
ILTY
Doesn’t sell data, doesn’t show ads, doesn’t use conversations for training. Local-first storage by default. No advertising business model — subscription only.
Better for: ILTY — no advertising business model = no data-sharing incentive
Therapist Quality
BetterHelp
Varies significantly. Some excellent therapists, some not. Matching can require multiple tries.
ILTY
Consistent experience. AI doesn't have good or bad days.
Better for: Depends on luck with BetterHelp; consistent with ILTY
Medication
BetterHelp
Cannot prescribe medication directly. Some integration with psychiatric services.
ILTY
Cannot and does not address medication.
Better for: Neither (see a psychiatrist for medication)
Who wrote this: ILTY publishes this comparison, and ILTY is one of the two apps in it. We rank ourselves below competitors where they genuinely win — you’ll see several of those calls below. Read it with the bias in mind and check the other side’s claims too.
Our Honest Take
BetterHelp connects you with licensed therapists. For serious clinical conditions — major depression, anxiety disorders, trauma, OCD — professional human treatment matters, and ILTY isn’t a substitute. For those situations, find a therapist (BetterHelp, an in-person clinician, or a lower-cost option like Open Path Collective).
The challenge with BetterHelp is that the price and trust story don’t match what’s on the tin. $280-400/month. Some therapists reportedly use AI to draft replies without disclosing it. FTC settlement in 2023 for sharing health data with advertisers. Teladoc (parent) wrote down $720M on BetterHelp in 2024. Variable therapist quality. Refund complaints. These aren’t reasons to never use BetterHelp — they’re reasons to know what you’re paying for.
ILTY fills a different job: tough-love AI conversation for the everyday moments when you know what you need to do and you’re not doing it. $12.99/month, 24/7, no scheduling, no waiting, explicit about being AI. About 95% cheaper than BetterHelp on a monthly basis. For the “I need to talk through this Tuesday afternoon decision” moment, ILTY is the right-shaped tool.
Honest framing: if you’re going to pay for AI responses anyway (as some BetterHelp users reportedly are, without disclosure), you might as well pay for AI that’s labeled as AI, costs 95% less, and is honest about what it is. Use both if you can — a real therapist for the deep work, ILTY for the between-sessions moments. That’s usually the right combination.
The research behind this
Rankings on this page draw on The 2026 State of AI Mental Health Apps, our own study of 15 apps across 8 criteria. Crisis handling was tested by hand: the same four escalating messages typed into every app, screenshots kept. Four of them never produced a crisis number. Every score is published with the reasoning behind it, including ILTY’s, and the rubric is CC-BY if you would rather score apps yourself.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is ILTY trying to replace therapy?
No. ILTY is not a replacement for therapy, and we're clear about that. For serious mental health conditions, professional treatment is essential. ILTY is for everyday emotional support—the moments when you need to talk through something but don't need (or can't access) a therapist.
Is BetterHelp real therapy?
Yes. BetterHelp connects you with licensed therapists (psychologists, counselors, social workers) for real therapy sessions via text, phone, or video. The therapists are real, credentialed professionals.
Why is BetterHelp so expensive?
BetterHelp charges $300-400/month because you're paying for access to licensed human professionals. Therapists need to be paid. ILTY is AI-only, which dramatically reduces costs but also means you're not talking to a human.
Can I use both BetterHelp and ILTY?
Yes, many people do. Use BetterHelp for actual therapy sessions. Use ILTY between sessions when something comes up and you need to talk through it before your next appointment.
See for Yourself
The best way to know if ILTY is right for you is to try it. Free to download, with a one-week free trial.
More Comparisons
ILTY vs Talkspace
Compare ILTY with Talkspace's text-based therapy.
ILTY vs Cerebral
Compare ILTY with Cerebral's therapy and medication service.
ILTY vs 7 Cups
Compare ILTY with 7 Cups' peer-listener support.
ILTY vs Wysa
Compare ILTY with Wysa's AI + human coach approach.
Everything You Need to Know About Therapy
Our complete guide to types of therapy and how to find help.
New to Therapy
Exploring options before committing