Anxiety Medications: What Your Doctor Might Not Tell You

You're considering medication for anxiety. Maybe your doctor mentioned it. Maybe you're wondering if it could help. Maybe you've been prescribed something and you're not sure what to expect.

Medication conversations often happen in rushed appointments. You might walk away with a prescription but without a real understanding of what you're taking, how it works, or what to expect.

Here's a comprehensive, honest look at anxiety medications—the information your prescriber might not have time to fully explain.

Important disclaimer: This is educational information, not medical advice. Decisions about medication should be made with your healthcare provider, who knows your specific situation.

Understanding Anxiety Medications

Anxiety medications fall into several categories, each working differently and appropriate for different situations.

SSRIs/SNRIs: The Most Common First-Line Treatment

What they are: Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) and serotonin-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs) are antidepressants commonly prescribed for anxiety.

Common names: Sertraline (Zoloft), Escitalopram (Lexapro), Paroxetine (Paxil), Fluoxetine (Prozac), Venlafaxine (Effexor), Duloxetine (Cymbalta).

How they work: They increase serotonin (and norepinephrine for SNRIs) availability in the brain by preventing reuptake. Over time, this can reduce anxiety symptoms.

What your doctor might not emphasize:

• They take time. 4-6 weeks minimum for full effect. Many people give up too soon because they don't feel different after a week.

• You might feel worse first. Starting an SSRI can temporarily increase anxiety, cause insomnia, or produce uncomfortable side effects. This usually passes within 1-2 weeks.

• Side effects are common. Sexual dysfunction, weight changes, emotional blunting, drowsiness, nausea. Different medications have different side effect profiles—if one doesn't work, another might.

• Finding the right one is trial and error. There's no way to predict which SSRI will work best for you. It often takes trying a few.

• They don't make you feel "high" or euphoric. They gradually reduce anxiety over time. Many people don't feel dramatically different—they just notice they're reacting less intensely to stressors.

• Stopping can be hard. Discontinuation symptoms are real. If you stop, you need to taper slowly under medical supervision.

Benzodiazepines: Fast-Acting But Problematic

What they are: Fast-acting sedative medications that enhance GABA activity in the brain.

Common names: Alprazolam (Xanax), Lorazepam (Ativan), Clonazepam (Klonopin), Diazepam (Valium).

How they work: They almost immediately reduce anxiety by calming the central nervous system.

What your doctor might not emphasize:

• They work fast. Unlike SSRIs, benzos work within 30-60 minutes. This makes them useful for panic attacks or acute anxiety.

• They're addictive. Physical dependence can develop in weeks. Tolerance builds, meaning you need more to get the same effect. Withdrawal can be dangerous.

• They're not meant for daily long-term use. Benzos are appropriate for short-term use, acute situations, or as-needed for panic. Using them daily for months or years is problematic.

• They impair cognition. Memory, coordination, and judgment are affected. You shouldn't drive after taking them.

• Long-term use might worsen anxiety. Your brain adapts to the medication. When it wears off, anxiety can rebound worse than before.

• Many doctors are reluctant to prescribe them. Due to addiction potential and guidelines recommending against long-term use, you might encounter pushback.

Buspirone: The Underused Option

What it is: A non-benzodiazepine anti-anxiety medication.

How it works: Affects serotonin and dopamine receptors. The mechanism isn't fully understood.

What your doctor might not emphasize:

• It's not addictive. Unlike benzos, there's no dependence or abuse potential.

• It takes 2-4 weeks to work. Like SSRIs, it's not fast-acting. It's for generalized anxiety, not acute panic.

• Side effects are generally mild. Dizziness, headache, nausea. Usually less problematic than SSRIs.

• It doesn't help everyone. Response rates are mixed. For some people it works well; for others, not at all.

• It doesn't work as-needed. Unlike benzos, you can't take buspirone when you feel anxious. It only works with consistent daily use.

Beta Blockers: For Physical Symptoms

What they are: Medications primarily used for heart conditions, also useful for physical anxiety symptoms.

Common names: Propranolol (Inderal), Atenolol (Tenormin).

How they work: Block adrenaline's effects on the heart and body, reducing physical symptoms like racing heart, trembling, and sweating.

What your doctor might not emphasize:

• They don't reduce mental anxiety. Your thoughts will still race. But your body won't have the physical symptoms that feed the anxiety loop.

• Great for performance anxiety. Public speaking, presentations, interviews. Taken 30-60 minutes before.

• They're not controlled substances. Easy to prescribe, no addiction potential.

• They can cause fatigue. By slowing heart rate and blood pressure, they might make you feel sluggish.

Other Options

Hydroxyzine: An antihistamine with anti-anxiety effects. Not addictive. Causes drowsiness. Often used for anxiety that co-occurs with sleep problems.

Gabapentin/Pregabalin: Originally for seizures and nerve pain, sometimes prescribed for anxiety. Mixed evidence for effectiveness.

Tricyclic antidepressants and MAOIs: Older antidepressants that can help anxiety but have more side effects than SSRIs. Usually only used when other options fail.

What to Know Before Starting Medication

It's Not Either/Or

Medication works best alongside therapy, not instead of it. The combination of medication and therapy typically outperforms either alone.

Medication can reduce symptoms enough that you can engage effectively in therapy. Therapy gives you tools so you don't have to stay on medication forever (if you don't want to).

Finding the Right Medication Takes Time

The first medication you try might not be the one that works. Side effects might be intolerable. It might not be effective. This is frustrating but normal.

Be patient with the process. Communicate openly with your prescriber about what you're experiencing. Don't give up if the first option doesn't work.

Side Effects Often Improve

Many side effects are worst in the first 1-2 weeks and then diminish. If you can tolerate the initial discomfort, you might find it smooths out.

However, some side effects persist. If they significantly impact your quality of life, that medication might not be right for you.

You're Not Weak for Taking Medication

There's stigma around psychiatric medication. Some people feel like needing medication means they've "failed" at managing anxiety on their own.

This is like feeling ashamed for wearing glasses or taking insulin. Anxiety involves brain chemistry. Sometimes that chemistry needs support. Taking medication is using available tools, not admitting defeat.

You Might Not Need It Forever

For many people, medication is a temporary support while they develop other coping strategies. Others benefit from long-term use. Both approaches are valid.

Discuss with your prescriber what the long-term plan looks like.

Questions to Ask Your Prescriber

If you're considering medication, bring these questions to your appointment:

1. Why are you recommending this particular medication?
2. What side effects should I expect, and when should I be concerned?
3. How long until I feel effects?
4. What if it doesn't work? What's the next option?
5. How long do you anticipate I'll be on this?
6. What's the plan for stopping, if I eventually want to?
7. Are there interactions with other things I take (including supplements)?
8. What lifestyle changes should I make alongside medication?

If You're Already on Medication

If It's Not Working

Talk to your prescriber. Options include:

• Increasing the dose
• Adding another medication
• Switching to a different medication
• Adding therapy if you're not already doing it
• Investigating whether the diagnosis is accurate

If Side Effects Are Unbearable

Don't just stop—this can be dangerous, especially with SSRIs. Talk to your prescriber about:

• Trying a different medication in the same class
• Trying a different class entirely
• Adjusting the dose
• Adding something to counteract the side effect

If You Want to Stop

Work with your prescriber to taper slowly. Stopping abruptly can cause:

• Discontinuation syndrome (flu-like symptoms, "brain zaps," mood instability)
• Rebound anxiety worse than before
• Withdrawal effects (especially with benzodiazepines)

This isn't about addiction—it's about giving your brain time to adjust.

Medication + ILTY

Where does ILTY fit in a medication treatment plan?

ILTY can help you:

• Process how the medication makes you feel: Track side effects, notice changes, prepare for prescriber appointments.
• Work through anxiety that medication doesn't fully address: Medication reduces intensity; ILTY helps you work through the thoughts.
• Stay engaged with your mental health: Daily processing complements medical treatment.
• Bridge gaps: ILTY is available at 2am when your prescriber isn't.

ILTY isn't a replacement for medication or for the prescriber who manages it. It's a tool for the daily emotional work that happens alongside medical treatment.

---

Medication is one part of managing anxiety. ILTY is another. They work together, along with therapy, lifestyle changes, and support systems.

Try ILTY Free as part of your anxiety management toolkit.

---

Related Reading

• The Complete Anxiety Guide: Understanding anxiety from all angles.
• Panic Attack vs Anxiety Attack: What's the Difference?: Understanding acute anxiety symptoms.
• CBT vs DBT: Which Therapy Approach Is Right for You?: Complementing medication with the right therapy.